Connect with others who understand.

sign up log in
About MyFibroTeam

Little Evidence Pain Creams Work

Posted on February 14, 2019


By Robert Preidt, HealthDay Reporter

TUESDAY, Feb. 5, 2019 (HealthDay News) -- Despite their wide use, commercial pain creams and gels don't do much for chronic pain, a new report claims.

In fact, the government-funded study, ordered by U.S. Congress, found these creams/gels were no better than placebos, researchers said.


"Our study of nearly 400 pain patients suggests that people who use these compounded creams and gels are being taken advantage of, because the scientific evidence to support a benefit is not there," said study senior author Dr. Steven Cohen, director of pain research at Walter Reed National Military Medical Center.

The products can cost anywhere from $20 to thousands of dollars a tube, and billions are spent on them in the United States each year, the researchers said.

About one-third of U.S. adults have chronic pain, resulting in direct and indirect health care costs of about $600 billion a year, according to Cohen. He is also a professor of anesthesiology and critical care medicine at the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine in Baltimore.

Compounded creams and gels typically contain one or more anesthetic, analgesic, sedative, antidepressant, anti-seizure or muscle relaxant drugs.

The study was
conducted August 2015 to February 2018 and included 399 participants, aged 18 to 90. Nearly 43 percent were active duty military personnel, and the remaining participants were retired members of the military or dependents, such as spouses.

All the participants had pain in specific areas, such as the face, back, buttocks, neck, abdomen, chest, groin and/or up to two extremities. The average length of time they'd had pain was 6.7 years.


They had three types of pain: neuropathic, caused by disease or damage to the nerves, such as shingles or diabetes; nociceptive or non-neuropathic, caused by injury to tissue, such as burns or sprains; and mixed pain, caused by damage to the nerves and tissues, such as certain types of back pain.

Patients were told to apply either a compounded cream or a placebo cream (they didn't know which they were using) three times a day to the affected area, and to make entries in a pain diary twice a day. The diaries were used to measure the outcomes.

After the treatment period ended, the study found no statistically significant difference in pain score reductions between the placebo and compounded cream users.

The slight improvements experienced by all the participants were probably due to the placebo effect, Cohen noted.

"With the number of research participants studied as long as they were studied, we should have been able to see a statistically significant difference in pain reduction if these creams were actually working," Cohen said in a Hopkins news release.

"But we didn't see this in our data," he added. "The pain reduction we saw in patients being treated with the pain cream was nearly the same pain reduction we saw in placebo -- there was just not a large enough difference for the reduction to be scientifically meaningful."

The study was published Feb. 5 in the journal Annals of Internal Medicine.

The study participants were eligible for coverage under TRICARE, a health insurance plan provided by the U.S. Department of Defense, covering some active duty and retired military personnel and their family members.

TRICARE spent $259 million on compounded pain creams
in fiscal year 2013, and the cost increased to $746 million in 2014. In the first month of 2015, the Department of Defense spent about $6 million per day on the medications. In 2015, Medicare Part D paid out more than half a billion dollars for the creams, the researchers said.

SOURCE: Johns Hopkins Medicine, news release, Feb. 5, 2019
Copyright © 2019 All rights reserved.
Here are some questions and conversations from MyFibroTeam:

Have you used pain creams to help relieve your fibro pain?

Share your experience in the comments below or directly on MyFibroTeam.

A MyFibroTeam Member said:

That's interesting

posted 2 months ago

hug

Recent articles

Thousands of members of MyFibroTeam connect with one another and read each other's stories to...

Four Books About Fibromyalgia You Should Read

Thousands of members of MyFibroTeam connect with one another and read each other's stories to...
Article written by Kelly Crumrin Those of us living with pre-existing, chronic conditions such as...

Canceling Is Kindness: Keeping Safe From COVID-19 With Fibromyalgia

Article written by Kelly Crumrin Those of us living with pre-existing, chronic conditions such as...
Could You Have Spondyloarthritis? People with spondyloarthritis, a form of inflammatory arthritis...

QUIZ: Could I Have Spondyloarthritis?

Could You Have Spondyloarthritis? People with spondyloarthritis, a form of inflammatory arthritis...
Eat healthier. Exercise more. Learn a new skill. Pay off a credit card. Many of us have made...

Setting Intentions for 2020 With Fibromyalgia

Eat healthier. Exercise more. Learn a new skill. Pay off a credit card. Many of us have made...
This time of the year can be overwhelming with expectations around the holidays, and living with...

Practicing Gratitude with Fibromyalgia

This time of the year can be overwhelming with expectations around the holidays, and living with...
Living with fibromyalgia may change your holidays, but you can still have enjoyable and...

How to Enjoy the Holidays Despite Fibromyalgia

Living with fibromyalgia may change your holidays, but you can still have enjoyable and...
When you have fibromyalgia, it can be challenging to get a good night’s sleep. Insomnia, sleep...

Fibromyalgia and Insomnia

When you have fibromyalgia, it can be challenging to get a good night’s sleep. Insomnia, sleep...
We all respond differently to information about our health. After learning you have fibromyalgia,...

You’ve Just Been Diagnosed With Fibromyalgia. Now What?

We all respond differently to information about our health. After learning you have fibromyalgia,...
If you’re experiencing frequent itching with fibromyalgia, you’re not alone. MyFibroTeam members...

Itching with Fibromyalgia

If you’re experiencing frequent itching with fibromyalgia, you’re not alone. MyFibroTeam members...
Members of MyFibroTeam search for ways to increase their energy as they battle fatigue, one of...

Increasing Energy with Fibromyalgia

Members of MyFibroTeam search for ways to increase their energy as they battle fatigue, one of...
MyFibroTeam My fibromyalgia Team

Two Ways to Get Started with MyFibroTeam

Become a Member

Connect with others who are living with fibromyalgia. Get members only access to emotional support, advice, treatment insights, and more.

sign up

Become a Subscriber

Get the latest articles about fibromyalgia sent to your inbox.

Not now, thanks

Privacy policy
MyFibroTeam My fibromyalgia Team

Thank you for signing up.

close